Alicia Silverstone

Sophie

Karl Glusman

Elliot

Catherine Curtin

Peggy

Sergi Martos

French Waiter

Britne Oldford

Sam

Monica Rae Summers Gonzalez

Off-Broadway Bartender

Kyle Bary

Dan

Paul McCallion

Morgan (Sophie's Assistant)

John Wollman

David

Esteban Benito

Paul

Mike Rob

Jordan

Tammy Blanchard

Amanda (Sophie's Sister)

Sorika Horng

Jane

Nicole Annunziata

Amy