Aaron Eckhart

Bill

Jessica Alba

Lucy

Elizabeth Banks

Jess

Logan Lerman

The Kid

Kristen Wiig

Jane Whittman

Timothy Olyphant

Chip Johnson

Holmes Osborne

Mr. Jacoby

Reed Diamond

Paul

Jason Sudeikis

Jim Whittman

Todd Louiso

John Jr.

Marisa Coughlan

Laura

Constance Barron

Mrs. Jacoby

Joseph Moynihan

Jim (uncredited)

Gabriel Basso

Kid with Cancer (uncredited)